Skip to main content

Report claims that Germany’s toll roads are too expensive

Toll roads built in Germany under public-private partnerships deals has been costing taxpayers much more than originally planned, a government spending watchdog has claimed. An internal report the German Federal Audit Office (BRH) has criticised PPP plans for private motorway construction as laid out by the Minister of Transport and Digital Infrastructure Alexander Dobrindt. According to the report in the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, five out of the total six motorways built through a PPP deal resu
January 4, 2016 Read time: 2 mins
Toll roads built in Germany under public-private partnerships deals has been costing taxpayers much more than originally planned, a government spending watchdog has claimed.

An internal report the German Federal Audit Office (BRH) has criticised PPP plans for private motorway construction as laid out by the Minister of Transport and Digital Infrastructure Alexander Dobrindt.

According to the report in the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, five out of the total six motorways built through a PPP deal resulted in additional costs of almost €2 billion.

Also, PPPs usually exclude smaller businesses because of the large funding that is needed to compete. The BRH is in disagreement with the Ministry of Transport regarding whether an interest change risk can be considered in the economic feasibility study.

BRH’s criticism comes before the government is due to introduce a toll sometime this year for non-Germans driving on Germany’s Autobahns. Dobrindt has said in the past that the toll could bring in around €500 million euros each year, which would be invested in transport infrastructure.

However, the planned toll, first announced last May, could be postponed or withdrawn, depending on the outcome of a European Union legal challenge to its implementation.

Media reports have suggested that foreign drivers would pay around €130 euros a year to use Germany's Autobahns. They could, though, but short-term passes costing around €30 euros for between 10 days and two-months.

Related Content

  • Tolling model for funding road development
    April 4, 2017
    Road tolling is being used worldwide as a way to develop highway infrastructure, with road users paying for access. Tolled roads are not a new concept and date back centuries, but in recent times, as governments have struggled to fund highway development programmes directly, tolling has increased in popularity worldwide. In Africa, Asia, Europe, Latin America and North America, tolled highways are now extremely well established. The specifics of the business models vary but state-owned toll-road firms ty
  • French infrastructure to be privatised?
    July 4, 2012
    How will the deep cuts hitting France's national budget affect French roads and highways? Gordon Feller discusses France has one of the most modern transport systems in Europe, the result of decades of public spending on the sector as well as other infrastructure. The government historically has awarded contracts to build infrastructure to French construction and engineering companies, some of which are now among the world's largest contractors. Among other achievements, France's infrastructure programme re
  • Transport forum report
    January 24, 2014
    The International Transport Forum (ITF) has published a new report on how better regulated Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs) can improve funding and delivery of transport infrastructure. The ITF highlights how PPPs have become an important tool for governments to attract private finance for infrastructure investments. In the face of tight budgets, PPPs are seen as a means to maintain transport investment and limit public spending at the same time.
  • Germany builds its first major PPI autobahn project
    July 7, 2015
    Rebuilding of one of the oldest motorways in Germany is testing out the possibilities for public-private project road construction reports Adrian Greeman A freshly renovated section of the A8 Autobahn in southern Germany will be watched with some interest this summer as traffic begins driving along its rebuilt carriageway and additional third lanes. That is not because of any special road features, other than a distinctive reddish colour to its concrete surface, but because it is a first fullscale public