Skip to main content

Report claims that Germany’s toll roads are too expensive

Toll roads built in Germany under public-private partnerships deals has been costing taxpayers much more than originally planned, a government spending watchdog has claimed. An internal report the German Federal Audit Office (BRH) has criticised PPP plans for private motorway construction as laid out by the Minister of Transport and Digital Infrastructure Alexander Dobrindt. According to the report in the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, five out of the total six motorways built through a PPP deal resu
January 4, 2016 Read time: 2 mins
Toll roads built in Germany under public-private partnerships deals has been costing taxpayers much more than originally planned, a government spending watchdog has claimed.

An internal report the German Federal Audit Office (BRH) has criticised PPP plans for private motorway construction as laid out by the Minister of Transport and Digital Infrastructure Alexander Dobrindt.

According to the report in the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, five out of the total six motorways built through a PPP deal resulted in additional costs of almost €2 billion.

Also, PPPs usually exclude smaller businesses because of the large funding that is needed to compete. The BRH is in disagreement with the Ministry of Transport regarding whether an interest change risk can be considered in the economic feasibility study.

BRH’s criticism comes before the government is due to introduce a toll sometime this year for non-Germans driving on Germany’s Autobahns. Dobrindt has said in the past that the toll could bring in around €500 million euros each year, which would be invested in transport infrastructure.

However, the planned toll, first announced last May, could be postponed or withdrawn, depending on the outcome of a European Union legal challenge to its implementation.

Media reports have suggested that foreign drivers would pay around €130 euros a year to use Germany's Autobahns. They could, though, but short-term passes costing around €30 euros for between 10 days and two-months.

Related Content

  • Colombia’s ANI agency is driving forward the 4G PPP programme
    April 4, 2016
    Andrade Moreno is a man on a mission. The head of Colombia's infrastructure agency ANI explains how the organisation is giving foreign companies increasing confidence to invest time and money in the country. David Arminas reports Change, especially when it touches the highest levels of South American business and politics, can bring with it personal danger. Luis Fernando Andrade Moreno, president of Colombia's National Infrastructure Agency - ANI - was aware of this when he took on the role in 2011. B
  • New international trade crossing linking Canada and US
    June 9, 2015
    The Detroit River is short, only 45km, and narrow in places, less than 1km. Around a quarter of the annual $658 billion Canada-US trade crosses over the river. That’s $160 billion worth of goods trucked each year between Detroit in the US state of Michigan and the Canadian city of Windsor in the province of Ontario - the Windsor-Detroit Corridor. There are several types of crossings, but the vast majority of commercial traffic must use the 2.3km Ambassador Bridge (see box). A new bridge was initially prop
  • Slovak government stands firm over R2 Expressway, including Soroska Tunnel
    August 11, 2017
    Jan Durisin, head of Slovakia’s motorway operator NDS, has said that the R2 expressway, will go ahead despite watchdog fears of poor value for money. Completion of the R2, that includes the Soroska Tunnel, remains 2024, he told Slovakian news agencies. NDS, he said, will start looking for a contractor to start work in 2018 on a stretch of the expressway near the town of Roznava. R2 is a 360km route that will run from Kosice in the east across the country to Trenčín, near the Czech border in the west. It wil
  • Sourcing road financing for East Africa’s network expansion
    December 4, 2015
    East Africa’s ambitious road expansion programme is seeing the network expand significantly – Shem Oirere writes The East Africa countries of Kenya, Tanzania, Uganda and Rwanda have announced ambitious road sector expansion plans in the 2015/16 financial year. This is despite their national budgets being weighed down by huge deficits and persisting lack of capacity to spend resources allocated to the sector in previous years. With the huge budget deficits, the countries will have to look for alternati