Hybrid cars are safer because they are heavier claim

Passengers in hybrid-powered cars are about 25% less likely to be injured in a crash than those in their conventional-powered counterparts, according to research released by the Highway Loss Data Institute, which claims that the additional weight of the hybrid engine adds an extra layer of safety over similar, non-hybrid cars. Cars with hybrid engines typically weigh about 10% more than their conventionally-powered twins.
May 14, 2012 Read time: 2 mins
RSSPassengers in hybrid-powered cars are about 25% less likely to be injured in a crash than those in their conventional-powered counterparts, according to research released by the 5523 Highway Loss Data Institute (HDLI), which claims that the additional weight of the hybrid engine adds an extra layer of safety over similar, non-hybrid cars. Cars with hybrid engines typically weigh about 10% more than their conventionally-powered twins.

“This new research shows that hybrid engines not only save fuel, but they may save lives,” claimed Candysse Miller, executive director of the 5524 Insurance Information Network of California. “Choosing a car that saves gas doesn’t necessarily mean compromising on safety.”

The research compared 25 hybrid cars and their petrol-powered versions of the same vehicles, including the 2728 Toyota Camry, 3423 Ford Fusion and the 2288 Honda Accord. The Toyota Prius and Honda Insight, which are not available with petrol-power only, were not included in the study. However the findings make no mention of any analysis into the types of people who choose to buy hybrid cars and does not reveal any evaluation of their driving styles, which may show a somewhat different perspective on the research. Experience would suggest that owners of hybrid cars are less likely to be people who drive at speed or who are attracted by high performance, details that the research seems to have overlooked.

A separate analysis by the HLDI found that hybrids may be as much as 20% more likely to be involved in collisions with pedestrians than their petrol-powered counterparts, likely due to their quiet engines. The US 2467 National Highway Traffic Safety Administration is currently developing policy to equip electric and hybrid cars with sounds to alert unsuspecting pedestrians.

Related Content

  • Injury severity increases for Michigan motorcyclists
    June 6, 2013
    A new report by the Highway Loss Data Institute (HLDI) in the US reveals that injury severity has increased in the US state of Michigan following a change to helmet laws. The study is based on data taken from insurance claims and shows that these costs have increased substantially since the helmet law was changed in Michigan back in 2012. Previous to the law change motorcyclists in Michigan were required to wear helmets whilst riding, which had been in place for over 40 years. The law was changed and only m
    Read More
  • Car for sale
    August 14, 2014
    A somewhat less than proud parent recently posted an advert for his son’s rather battered Honda online, saying the car was now suitable only for spares. The teenaged son had crashed the Honda Civic only days after passing his test, luckily escaping injury to everything but his pride. The advert attracted widespread attention, much to the embarrassment of the young driver who also claimed he was not driving fast at the time of the crash. The parents say that the cost of the car and the insurance means their
    Read More
  • Risk warnings for UK revealed with new data
    May 9, 2013
    New data from the UK reveals key information about road risk factors both across the country and in capital London. A new report reveals that around 68% of pedestrian casualties are adults who are at greatest risk on weekend evenings and after consuming alcohol. Meanwhile another separate study in London reveals that cyclists are not at fault in most crashes in which they are involved.
    Read More
  • Quiet cars causing concerns for pedestrians
    March 30, 2015
    Data from the UK reveals that quiet electric vehicles or hybrids operating in electric mode pose particular problems for pedestrians. A report has found that such vehicles are 40% more likely to be involved in a traffic incident involving a pedestrian than a conventional combustion-engined vehicle. The report adds that partially sighted or blind people face the highest risks, while children and older people are also at risk. This follows earlier research from Japan, highlighting the risks to pedestrians pos
    Read More

Highlighted Content