Skip to main content

Europe's Galileo satellite navigation project is a ''stupid idea''

The head of the German firm contracted to build 14 satellites for Europe's Galileo satellite navigation system called the entire project a "stupid idea," according to a leaked diplomatic cable published in Norway's Aftenposten newspaper.The head of the German firm contracted to build 14 satellites for Europe’s Galileo satellite navigation system called the entire project a "stupid idea," according to a leaked diplomatic cable published in Norway’s Aftenposten newspaper. Aftenposten said the cable quotes Be
March 6, 2012 Read time: 2 mins
The head of the German firm contracted to build 14 satellites for Europe’s Galileo satellite navigation system called the entire project a "stupid idea," according to a leaked diplomatic cable published in Norway’s Aftenposten newspaper.

Aftenposten said the cable quotes Berry Smutny, CEO of OHB-System AG, telling American diplomats at the US Embassy in Berlin during a meeting on 2 October, 2009, that the entire project was "a waste of EU taxpayers' money championed by French interests."

However, the cable added that Smutny said he would "gladly accept contracts to build the satellites," and that he believed that European navigational needs could already be served by GPS instead of Galileo.

Last Thursday, in response to the Aftenposten story, OHB issued a statement saying that Smutny denies making the reported comments. Yesterday, however, the OHB supervisory board announced that it had passed a unanimous resolution to revoke Smutny’s appointment to the position of CEO of the company.

“The General Assembly and the Supervisory Board saw no alternative to this decision in order to effectively avert any further damage to the company on the part of customers, political representatives and the public at large,” the company stated.

OHB’s contract to build 14 satellites that will be used in the Galileo constellation is worth US$742 million.

Meanwhile, today, the EC will present its midterm review on progress in the development of Europe’s satellite navigation programmes to date, including the start of operations of the EGNOS system, the deployment of two experimental satellites and the allotment of the necessary construction and engineering work to subcontractors. In addition the future directions of Galileo are considered in the review.

Related Content

  • Prague chosen for Galileo HQ
    March 15, 2012
    The Czech capital Prague has been chosen to host the headquarters of Europe’s Galileo satellite navigation programme which is expected to begin initial services in 2014 with a limited number of satellites.
  • Europe orders eight more Galileo satellites
    March 19, 2012
    The European Commission on Friday issued a contract worth some US$330 million for eight more satellites for its Galileo satellite-navigation network, bringing the total number in production by a German-UK consortium to 22 and keeping the programme on track to be fully operational by the end of the decade.
  • Do we need satellites for accurate navigation?
    April 24, 2012
    Dr Michael Milford from Queensland University of Technology's (QUT) Science and Engineering Faculty in Australia has revealed details of research that dispenses with GPS satellites and uses cameras instead to make road navigation a far cheaper and simpler task. "At the moment you need three satellites in order to get a decent GPS signal and even then it can take a minute or more to get a lock on your location," he said. "There are some places geographically, where you just can't get satellite signals and ev
  • More satellites, more signals
    July 20, 2012
    Greater GPS accuracy suggests closer tolerances for surveying and machine control functions What happens in the future for GPS surveying and machine control could depend on satellite choice and signals. Right now there are around 30 satellites in orbit, largely built by the US, but by 2012 that could rise to 120 as Europe, China, India and Russia fully enter the market. A chequered history has faced the European's Galileo system. At long last, the finance appears to be in place and the European Commission a