Skip to main content

Report claims that Germany’s toll roads are too expensive

Toll roads built in Germany under public-private partnerships deals has been costing taxpayers much more than originally planned, a government spending watchdog has claimed. An internal report the German Federal Audit Office (BRH) has criticised PPP plans for private motorway construction as laid out by the Minister of Transport and Digital Infrastructure Alexander Dobrindt. According to the report in the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, five out of the total six motorways built through a PPP deal resu
January 4, 2016 Read time: 2 mins
Toll roads built in Germany under public-private partnerships deals has been costing taxpayers much more than originally planned, a government spending watchdog has claimed.

An internal report the German Federal Audit Office (BRH) has criticised PPP plans for private motorway construction as laid out by the Minister of Transport and Digital Infrastructure Alexander Dobrindt.

According to the report in the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, five out of the total six motorways built through a PPP deal resulted in additional costs of almost €2 billion.

Also, PPPs usually exclude smaller businesses because of the large funding that is needed to compete. The BRH is in disagreement with the Ministry of Transport regarding whether an interest change risk can be considered in the economic feasibility study.

BRH’s criticism comes before the government is due to introduce a toll sometime this year for non-Germans driving on Germany’s Autobahns. Dobrindt has said in the past that the toll could bring in around €500 million euros each year, which would be invested in transport infrastructure.

However, the planned toll, first announced last May, could be postponed or withdrawn, depending on the outcome of a European Union legal challenge to its implementation.

Media reports have suggested that foreign drivers would pay around €130 euros a year to use Germany's Autobahns. They could, though, but short-term passes costing around €30 euros for between 10 days and two-months.

Related Content

  • The drive for US road funding: will corporate America get a seat?
    September 13, 2017
    Trumponomics aims to use public money for pump-priming an even greater amount of cash from the private sector to improve America’s crumbling roads. But is political will matching corporate America’s enthusiasm for more private investment, asks David Arminas If there were ever a test case for comparing public-private partnerships and design-build contracts, the recently completed Ohio River Bridges Project is it (see previous article).
  • German road maintenance spending needs to be increased?
    July 8, 2015
    Germany’s audit office is calling for increased spending on roads maintenance. The audit office has criticised the road and autobahn budget set by Germany’s Ministry of Transport for the 2016 to 2030 period. The German Government has set its €3.8 billion annual spending for the 2011 to 2025 period based on the conditions of roads in 2010. However the audit office says that the future costs will be much higher.
  • EIB produces PPP report
    February 28, 2012
    The European Investment Bank (EIB) has released a significant study aimed at exploring and promoting Public-Private Partnerships (PPP) to fund critical infrastructure projects across nine countries in North Africa and the Middle East.
  • US DOTs in critical funding battle
    February 9, 2012
    In the US, state DOTs are preparing for the upcoming reauthorisation battle in a tough economic and political climate. Set to expire by the end of the year, the bill is a critical funding source for many transportation projects in the US. However transportation officials in the US are facing a tough battle as the political and economic climate has changed considerably since the last reauthorisation was passed, shortly after President Obama's inauguration in January 2009. Since then, the recession has contin