Skip to main content

Reduced traffic may not mean fewer crashes

Reduced traffic may not mean that there are fewer crashes on the world’s roads.
By MJ Woof May 8, 2020 Read time: 2 mins
Lower traffic volumes are being seen on the world’s roads at present, though there is concern over the risk of crashes - image courtesy of Mike Woof

The current Corona Virus pandemic has resulted in a significant drop in vehicle traffic around the world. However, there is mounting concern over road safety at present. Early figures suggest that the rate of of crashes has not dropped significantly.

According to the European Transport Safety Commission (ETSC), there has been an unprecedented reduction in traffic volumes in Europe following the implementation of  movement restrictions arising from the COVID-19 pandemic. But the latest data suggests that road fatality rates have not dropped at the same rate. There are even suggestions that in some locations, road deaths have increased.

A full analysis has yet to be carried out. However, this preliminary data provides significant cause for concern.

Information from the GPS technology provider Tom Tom for several of Europe’s key cities reveals that traffic volumes have been slashed by 70-85% in the countries that have introduced movement restrictions. And according to TRL, traffic volumes on the UK’s motorways have fallen 75%.

A full analysis of traffic volumes and crash rates has yet to be completed. And this is complicated by the fact that not all countries are currently compiling accurate traffic data at present.

But in the Netherlands some data is already being recorded and this reveals that the number of crashes has dropped by 50% since movement restrictions were introduced. However, the Netherlands has not yet compiled full data on either accident severity or injury rates.

In Ireland road deaths actually reached a peak in March, after the movement restrictions were first implemented. Meanwhile, in Italy the strict restrictions on movement have resulted in a drop in road deaths of 70%. Similarly in France and Spain, the movement restrictions have been enforced strictly and road deaths have fallen by 40% and 47% respectively, according to official data.

There is widespread concern that some drivers are taking advantage of empty roads in Belgium, Denmark, France and the UK to hit high speeds according to the ETSC. Denmark’s official data shows a 10% increase in speeding. And similar reports on an increase in the incidence of speeding are being given by police in parts of the US and Australia.

But until a full analysis of data is available, it is too early to compile an accurate picture of road crash rates.

Related Content

  • French road accidents continue to increase
    February 22, 2012
    The latest official data shows that France’s worrying trend for increased road accident levels is continuing.
  • Managing traffic demand is crucial
    June 25, 2012
    Congestion charging can be an effective measure to aid traffic management in major cities. As vehicle use continues to grow worldwide, and fastest of all in developing nations, the problem of congestion is becoming worse in many cities. The mega cities of the developing world suffer particularly in this regard, with infrastructure unable to cope with current traffic volumes, let alone anticipated vehicle numbers for even the near future.
  • Safer French roads or incorrect estimation?
    February 12, 2014
    Official figures for French road safety reveal a small drop in fatalities for January 2014 compared with January 2013. However these results have been queried over possible inaccuracies and inconsistencies. According to the official body Sécurité Routière, 238 people were killed in traffic accidents in January 2014, down 0.5% compared to January 2013. However, the number of crashes rose 7.5% during the period, leading to an increase in injuries of 10.6% to 5,694 in January 2014. The increased crash figures
  • Risk for elderly on Japanese roads
    January 7, 2016
    Japan’s National Police Agency has revealed that the country’s road death figures increased slightly in 2015 compared with 2014. Total road fatalities for Japan in 2015 stood at 4,117, an increase of 0.1% from the previous year. There were 536,789 crashes in Japan during 2015, which injured 665,126 people. Of particular concern is the data showing that traffic deaths for those aged 65 or over rose by 2.5% to 2,247 in all, a worrying 54.6% of the total road fatality figure. Official information has not so fa