Skip to main content

Finland reverses its plan to impose user-pay roads

The Finnish government has axed controversial plans to privatise the operation of a large number of major roads and turn them into user-pay infrastructure. But transport Minister Anne Berner also announced that the government would now keep a tax on new car sales. The tax was going to be scrapped as part of the move to make road users pay tolls. Berner had recently announced that the government would put the operation of major highways under a new stand-alone agency that would engage the private secto
January 24, 2017 Read time: 3 mins
The Finnish government has axed controversial plans to privatise the operation of a large number of major roads and turn them into user-pay infrastructure.

But transport Minister Anne Berner also announced that the government would now keep a tax on new car sales. The tax was going to be scrapped as part of the move to make road users pay tolls.

Berner had recently announced that the government would put the operation of major highways under a new stand-alone agency that would engage the private sector to maintain roads and recoup their costs through user-pay tolling.

The daily Helsingin Sanomat reported that the controversial reform lacked the support of the smaller political parties within the National Coalition and Finns Party.

Iltalehti, a daily tabloid newspaper, reported that a poll of 1,000 people, which it had commissioned, showed that 70% of the public were against the reforms. Still, more than half agreed that the current model of taxing motorists needed to be changed.

Finland has around 500,000km of main thoroughfares, most of them privately owned or forest tracks. Only about 78,000km of the roadways are state-owned, including 900km of highway.

Last October, the Helsinki Court of Appeal reduced some of the fines previously imposed upon paving companies relating to an asphalt cartel that had operated between 1994 and 2002. A statement by the company 3064 Lemminkäinen said that, where it was the only defendant, the Court of Appeal ordered Lemminkäinen to pay 18 claimants damages of around €6 million which is about €9 million less than a lower District Court had ordered.

“As regards the 12 other claims, where Lemminkäinen and other asphalt industry companies were defendants, the Court of Appeal ordered the defendants to pay eight claimants damages approximately €14 million in capital, which is approximately €5 million less than the District Court had ordered. In these claims, Lemminkäinen's liability to pay is partly joint and several together with other defendants.”

The case has been rumbling on since 2009 when a lower court ordered seven Finnish asphalt industry companies - Lemminkäinen, Valtatie, Skanska Asfaltti, NCC/ Interasfaltti, Rudus Asfaltti, SA-Capital and Super Asfaltti - to pay an infringement fine. The infringement fine imposed on Lemminkäinen was €68 million, according to the company.

Lemminkäinen is one of the largest paving operations in northern Europe. It employs around 4,800 people and had ales in 2015 of around €1.9 billion.

"We are satisfied with the decisions of the Court of Appeal to the extent our appeals were accepted. Our daily operations will continue as planned, focusing on step by step improving our operational result and competitiveness in all our operations," said Casimir Lindholm, president and chief of Lemminkäinen.

For more information on companies in this article

Related Content

  • Rebuilding a historic bridge linking the US and Canada
    March 8, 2016
    While many road authorities in North America are finding it difficult to stretch their bridge assets beyond half a century, one bridge is closing in on its centenary - David Arminas reports The international Peace Bridge, connecting the Canadian province of Ontario with the US state of New York, is 88 years young this year, and still going strong.
  • Landmark ruling by European Commission says tolling existing highways is illegal
    April 25, 2012
    The European Commission has warned Portugal to change national rules on the introduction of tolling that are contrary to Community law, a decision that has widespread implications for similar schemes throughout the rest of Europe depending on how what is becoming a complex legal tangle is resolved. In November, 2010, the Aveiro municipality filed a formal complaint against the Portuguese Government to the European Commission objecting to a tolling scheme on the old SCUT highway. It argued that the system wa
  • Solar roads such as Colas’s Wattway could be the right way
    April 26, 2016
    Peter Harrop, chairman of independent research and consultancy IDTechEx, considers arguments in favour of solar roads Nowadays a major trend is the move to off-grid clean energy created by “energy harvesting” to produce electricity where it is needed. This is more controllable and increasingly at lower cost than grid power or diesel gensets, cleaner, and often less subject to interruption. It is taking new forms as revealed in the IDTechEx Research report, “High Power Energy Harvesting 2016-2026”.
  • Solar roads such as Colas’s Wattway could be the right way
    April 26, 2016
    Peter Harrop, chairman of independent research and consultancy IDTechEx, considers arguments in favour of solar roads Nowadays a major trend is the move to off-grid clean energy created by “energy harvesting” to produce electricity where it is needed. This is more controllable and increasingly at lower cost than grid power or diesel gensets, cleaner, and often less subject to interruption. It is taking new forms as revealed in the IDTechEx Research report, “High Power Energy Harvesting 2016-2026”.