Skip to main content

Us bridges pose cause for concern

On Aug 1st 2017, it was 10 years since the I-35W Bridge in Minneapolis collapsed. The bridge had been classified as structurally deficient and was undergoing repair at the time. However the repairs focussed on the decking rather than the structure, with the additional weight of the extra asphalt layers and the construction machinery parked adding to the total load and contributing to the collapse.
August 2, 2017 Read time: 3 mins

On Aug 1st 2017, it was 10 years since the I-35W Bridge in Minneapolis collapsed. The bridge had been classified as structurally deficient and was undergoing repair at the time. However the repairs focussed on the decking rather than the structure, with the additional weight of the extra asphalt layers and the construction machinery parked adding to the total load and contributing to the collapse.

The disaster sparked awareness in the state of bridges in the US, with widespread concern that so many were in poor condition.
 
The 920 American Road & Transportation Builders Association (ARTBA) recently looked at US Federal Government data to see what progress has been made in repairing bridges since the collapse. 
 
States have devoted significant resources to bridge work, according to ARTBA. The value of bridge construction increased 39%, from US$23.2 billion in 2007 to $32.3 billion in 2016, according to the US Census Bureau. During the same time period, highway and street construction activity increased just 8%, from $54.6 billion to $59.2 billion.
 
But in spite of the ramp up in investment, this has not been sufficient to address improvements to US bridges sufficiently and concerns remain.
 
In 2016, there were 55,710 structurally compromised bridges, a 24.5% reduction compared to the 73,817 back in 2007, according to ARTBA’s analysis of the 2364 US Department of Transportation’s National Bridge Inventory database.
 
At current pace, it would take more than three decades to replace or repair all the bridges with structural issues, according to ARTBA Chief Economist Dr Alison Premo Black, who conducted the analysis.
 
A long-term infrastructure package from Congress and a permanent revenue solution to the Highway Trust Fund would help states make greater progress on fixing deteriorating bridges, according to Dr Black. Federal investment supports over half of all state highway and bridge construction programmes.
 
Nor is the problem likely to get any better. The challenges will only continue to grow in the future. The average age of a structurally deficient bridge in the US is 67 years, compared to 39 years for non-deficient bridges. In 2007, the average age of a structurally deficient bridge was 60 years, compared to 34 years for non-deficient.  
 
To help ensure public safety, bridge decks and support structures are regularly inspected for deterioration and remedial action. They are rated on a scale of zero to nine; with nine meaning the bridge is in excellent condition. A bridge is classified as structurally deficient and in need of repair if the rating for a key component is four or below. While these bridges may not be imminently unsafe, they are in need of attention.
 
The states with the biggest decrease in the number of structurally deficient bridges in the last 10 years: Oklahoma (2,458), California (1,861), Pennsylvania (1,466), Texas (1,350), Missouri (1,282), Mississippi, (1,010), Ohio (1,008), Kansas (856), Alabama (712) and Indiana (536).  
 
States with an increased number of deficient bridges include: West Virginia (174), Idaho (52), Arizona (27), Delaware (22) and Rhode Island (21).

Related Content

  • InspectTech is right on time
    February 6, 2017
    All 15 US states using Bentley’s AssetWise InspectTech software achieved reporting compliance with annual Federal Highway Administration’s MAP-21 National Bridge Inventory and National Bridge Element schemes. Taylor Gilmore, product manager for AssetWise InspectTech, said the software was used to inspect over 175,000 bridges for their clients’ 2016 Federal Highway NBI and NBE data reports. Faced with ageing bridge infrastructure nationwide, FHWA’s MAP-21 performance-based programme is designed to maximis
  • US road crashes increasing for 2015?
    August 19, 2015
    There is mounting concern in the US at the high number of crashes during 2015. For the first seven months of 2015, there has been a 14% increase in the number of traffic fatalities compared with the same period in 2014. The data shows that there were 18,630 road deaths in this period, with over 2.2 million serious injuries. This is a notable increase and should the trend continue it will mean that 2015 will have had the highest rate of road deaths since 2007. The cause (or causes) of the increase in road de
  • Strong response for ARTBA’s student infrastructure video competition
    October 14, 2013
    A very strong response has been seen for the 3rd Annual Student Transportation Video Contest run by the Washington, DC-based American Road & Transportation Builders Association (ARTBA). Illinois high school and University of Maryland college students took top honours in this national video contest on America’s transportation network. The association received more than 40 entries this year in two categories. Sponsored by ARTBA’s Research and Education Division (RED), the contest aims to raise awareness about
  • Securing safer transportation infrastructure through non-destructive technology
    June 16, 2014
    Kevin Vine reports on the use of non-destructive testing for structural analysis of bridges Seven years ago, the overpass collapse in Laval, Québec that led to the death of five people brought to light severe issues with the state of the country’s bridges and transportation infrastructure. More recently, a crack in the Champlain Bridge to Montreal that forced over 160,000 commuters to find alternate routes to work reaffirmed a need for greater emphasis on early detection before a crisis occurs.