Skip to main content

Tolling model for funding road development

Road tolling is being used worldwide as a way to develop highway infrastructure, with road users paying for access. Tolled roads are not a new concept and date back centuries, but in recent times, as governments have struggled to fund highway development programmes directly, tolling has increased in popularity worldwide. In Africa, Asia, Europe, Latin America and North America, tolled highways are now extremely well established. The specifics of the business models vary but state-owned toll-road firms ty
April 4, 2017 Read time: 3 mins
Road tolling is being used worldwide as a way to develop highway infrastructure, with road users paying for access. Tolled roads are not a new concept and date back centuries, but in recent times, as governments have struggled to fund highway development programmes directly, tolling has increased in popularity worldwide.

In Africa, Asia, Europe, Latin America and North America, tolled highways are now extremely well established. The specifics of the business models vary but state-owned toll-road firms typically manage and oversee networks, with routes then operated by private sector firms under concession. Government funding for road development is in short supply however and many countries that have previously paid for highway networks through taxation are now considering switching to the tolled model. Germany was the first country in the world to develop high-speed highways with its Autobahn routes, which have traditionally been open to use.

In 2005 Germany introduced truck tolling for the Autobahn network and is now proposing a more comprehensive tolling system that will also include cars.

Initial plans met with protests but the German Government and the European Commission have come to an agreement over the plans to impose tolls for foreign cars on the Autobahn system. However, 11 other EU countries are less than happy with the German scheme and, headed by Austria, have discussed forming to bring a joint court case on the grounds that the toll discriminates against non-Germans.

The US too is looking to expand its use of tolled highways following its recent elections. There have been tolled highways in the shape of the Turnpike routes in the US for many decades, but its national Interstate system has traditionally been paid for through fuel taxation. That is now changing as the revenue from fuel taxation has not stayed in step with the needs of maintenance and expansion. States such as Florida have led the way in developing the modern tolled highway and more and more tolled routes are envisaged for the US in the future.

But not all moves to road tolling are proving successful. Finland’s Transport Ministry opted to halt its controversial plan to impose fees for road use, as well as proposals to remove taxes on new cars. The proposals called for a state-owned company to operate the country’s road network. Taxes on new cars would have been eliminated, with drivers instead paying to use the network. As the plan had been sharply criticised and was not a popular option, the Finnish Government opted to drop the proposals.

And tolled highways do not answer every transport issue. Questions still remain as to how best to link these tolled highways to towns and cities. France is recognised as having one of the best tolled highway networks in the world. But even in France, funding for its National routes has not met needs for upgrades and maintenance, so the connections from tolled highways to population centres and industrial areas have suffered over time.

Related Content

  • The US FAST Act: a job left unfinished
    April 4, 2016
    US roads and bridges are crumbling at an alarming rate as state governments wring their hands over the increasingly scarce money for repairs. Enter the FAST Act. But is it enough? US state transportation department officials, as well as highway contractors and operators, breathed a sigh of relief in December. For months the highways infrastructure sector waited anxiously to see where the necessary money for road projects would come from. For several years, the Highways Trust Fund – the usual way of paying f
  • Developments in tolling technology
    February 27, 2012
    Jason Barnes reviews the last few decades and the future of tolling technology. Tolling and charging technology has evolved significantly over the last three decades and that evolution is perhaps best illustrated by reductions in or complete removal of impedances to physical progress. Once, it was customary for a driver to pull up to a barrier, make some form of cash payment to a human operative in a booth, and then wait for the barrier to be raised before proceeding. Humans were eventually complemented and
  • Are road tolls the economic answer?
    November 12, 2012
    Tolling has been widely promoted as the answer to future road needs by many economists. The fundamental principle of a toll road is comparatively easy to understand: a driver wants to get from here to there and pays a small sum for the privilege. Drivers generally prefer to access roads without having to pay but the sums involved in toll roads tend to be comparatively low. For all but the most parsimonious, parting with a few coins to use a stretch of highway in good order is comparatively painless, made ev
  • Call for new ways of funding road infrastructure
    February 16, 2012
    In the first of a two-part article, Jack Opiola, a prominent global expert on transport policy and a leading member of IRF Geneva's Policy Committee on ITS, introduces the urgent need to develop new, more equitable revenue mechanisms to replace fuel taxes as a means of funding and maintaining road infrastructure