Italy’s horrific bridge collapse is a sign of a wider problem

The shocking collapse of a major highway bridge in the Italian city of Genoa has highlighted a major problem with regard to poor infrastructure condition in the country. Causing multiple fatalities, the cable-stayed Morandi Bridge suffered a spectacular failure of a central support. Homes have had to be evacuated and it seems likely that the bridge, opened in 1967, will now have to be demolished. However, warnings had been given. The unusual bridge design, with its thin deck and reinforced concrete stays
January 7, 2019 Read time: 3 mins
The shocking collapse of a major highway bridge in the Italian city of Genoa has highlighted a major problem with regard to poor infrastructure condition in the country. Causing multiple fatalities, the cable-stayed Morandi Bridge suffered a spectacular failure of a central support. Homes have had to be evacuated and it seems likely that the bridge, opened in 1967, will now have to be demolished.


However, warnings had been given. The unusual bridge design, with its thin deck and reinforced concrete stays, had been subject to frequent maintenance periods in the past. Two years ago a professor of engineering from Genoa University voiced concern over the condition of the Morandi Bridge. It is worth noting that the Wadi el Kuf Bridge in Libya by the same designer, Riccardo Morandi, has a similar arrangement of supports and cable stays. The Libyan bridge, first opened in 1972, was closed due to structural problems in 2017.

Questions have been asked as to why so many structures in Italy, particularly in the south, are suffering so badly from age. The quality of materials used during construction have been highly suspect in some instances, with organised crime linked to the poor engineering performance of many structures. Italy has seen 12 bridge collapses in recent years, four of which occurred in the south of the country.

Not since the collapse of the I-35 West bridge in Minneapolis in 2007 has there been such a public bridge disaster in a western developed nation. The I-35 W disaster in the US sparked examinations of other structures, showing some 20-25% of US bridges to be structurally deficient.

And nor is the problem restricted to Italy or the US. France, Germany and the UK for example all have their share of ageing bridges. It is a sign of the times, as structures erected in the 50s, 60s and 70s succumb to wear and tear. In many instances the wear can also be attributed to factors that were not properly understood at the time of design construction, such as the risk of long-term corrosion of unprotected reinforcing steel caused by chloride attack.

Bear in mind too that highways and bridges built in the 1960s were designed to handle far lower traffic volumes. For example, the UK’s Forth Road Bridge carried around 4 million vehicles/year after it was opened in 1964 and was designed to handle up to 11 million vehicles/year. However, by the time it was replaced by the new Queensferry Crossing, around 24 million vehicles/year were using the link. This is only part of the picture. Trucks had GVWs of just 20tonnes or so in the 1960s, compared with a maximum permitted weight of 44tonnes now in Europe, while a far higher percentage of freight is now carried by road. Given that stress levels increase exponentially with weight, using a rough calculation it can be assumed that the Forth Road Bridge was handling something like 16 times the daily stresses it had been designed for. No small wonder then that it wore out.

It would be naïve indeed to assume that crumbling transport infrastructure is solely an Italian problem stemming from ‘Mafia concrete’.

Related Content

  • Stronger crash barriers may be needed for heavier trucks
    January 4, 2013
    The European Road Federation (ERF) has voiced its concern that roadside barriers in Europe may have to be upgraded According to the ERF, the recent decision of the European Commission to allow cross-border movement of longer and heavier trucks, it is keen to raise awareness of the important implications such a move may have for road barriers. ‘Road safety barriers are designed and tested according to the maximum weight of vehicles circulating on Europe’s roads. The current European Norm (EN 1317) allows for
    Read More
  • Storage Facility
    May 22, 2018
    Many UK drivers use their vehicles to store highly unlikely items according to a study. Amongst the more peculiar items kept in cars by their owners are mannequins, a bale of hay, 52 pies, a Ouija board, a false leg, 160 hats, 24 rolling pins, a wicker reindeer, two single mattresses, a hamster cage, parts of a railway engine and a urine container. The study also found that 25% of drivers are ashamed of how dirty their vehicles are with a further 5% admitting to never cleaning their vehicles. The study was
    Read More
  • The hands-free debate is just one side of driver distraction
    August 13, 2019
    A debate about hands-free and hand-held phone use is welcome, but if we want to improve road safety and stop killing people it misses the point, explains Shaun Helman, TRL's chief scientist The Transport Committee’s report on driving and mobile phones is to be welcomed, for focusing attention on a pressing and growing road safety issue. As someone who provided evidence to the committee, I don’t need convincing that the use of a mobile device while controlling a vehicle is something that must be considered
    Read More
  • France’s bridge problem
    July 23, 2019
    As many as 25,000 bridges in France are considered in poor condition according to research. In a bid to tackle the problem, there have been calls for an annual budget of €120 million for the next 10 years to improve bridge condition. There are an estimated 200,000-250,000 bridges in France. An additional fund of €130 million/year is proposed to tackle the problem of ageing tunnels in France.
    Read More

Highlighted Content