Italy’s horrific bridge collapse is a sign of a wider problem

The shocking collapse of a major highway bridge in the Italian city of Genoa has highlighted a major problem with regard to poor infrastructure condition in the country. Causing multiple fatalities, the cable-stayed Morandi Bridge suffered a spectacular failure of a central support. Homes have had to be evacuated and it seems likely that the bridge, opened in 1967, will now have to be demolished. However, warnings had been given. The unusual bridge design, with its thin deck and reinforced concrete stays
January 7, 2019 Read time: 3 mins
The shocking collapse of a major highway bridge in the Italian city of Genoa has highlighted a major problem with regard to poor infrastructure condition in the country. Causing multiple fatalities, the cable-stayed Morandi Bridge suffered a spectacular failure of a central support. Homes have had to be evacuated and it seems likely that the bridge, opened in 1967, will now have to be demolished.


However, warnings had been given. The unusual bridge design, with its thin deck and reinforced concrete stays, had been subject to frequent maintenance periods in the past. Two years ago a professor of engineering from Genoa University voiced concern over the condition of the Morandi Bridge. It is worth noting that the Wadi el Kuf Bridge in Libya by the same designer, Riccardo Morandi, has a similar arrangement of supports and cable stays. The Libyan bridge, first opened in 1972, was closed due to structural problems in 2017.

Questions have been asked as to why so many structures in Italy, particularly in the south, are suffering so badly from age. The quality of materials used during construction have been highly suspect in some instances, with organised crime linked to the poor engineering performance of many structures. Italy has seen 12 bridge collapses in recent years, four of which occurred in the south of the country.

Not since the collapse of the I-35 West bridge in Minneapolis in 2007 has there been such a public bridge disaster in a western developed nation. The I-35 W disaster in the US sparked examinations of other structures, showing some 20-25% of US bridges to be structurally deficient.

And nor is the problem restricted to Italy or the US. France, Germany and the UK for example all have their share of ageing bridges. It is a sign of the times, as structures erected in the 50s, 60s and 70s succumb to wear and tear. In many instances the wear can also be attributed to factors that were not properly understood at the time of design construction, such as the risk of long-term corrosion of unprotected reinforcing steel caused by chloride attack.

Bear in mind too that highways and bridges built in the 1960s were designed to handle far lower traffic volumes. For example, the UK’s Forth Road Bridge carried around 4 million vehicles/year after it was opened in 1964 and was designed to handle up to 11 million vehicles/year. However, by the time it was replaced by the new Queensferry Crossing, around 24 million vehicles/year were using the link. This is only part of the picture. Trucks had GVWs of just 20tonnes or so in the 1960s, compared with a maximum permitted weight of 44tonnes now in Europe, while a far higher percentage of freight is now carried by road. Given that stress levels increase exponentially with weight, using a rough calculation it can be assumed that the Forth Road Bridge was handling something like 16 times the daily stresses it had been designed for. No small wonder then that it wore out.

It would be naïve indeed to assume that crumbling transport infrastructure is solely an Italian problem stemming from ‘Mafia concrete’.

Related Content

  • Forming iconic structures
    July 18, 2012
    Specially designed and constructed formwork is being used to create some iconic bridges worldwide The Golden Ears Bridge over the Fraser River will unite the municipalities of Richmond, New Westminister and Delta in the scenic British Columbia province of Canada. The bridge, part of a CAD$800 million (US$670 million) project, is an 'extra dosed' cable stayed bridge, which means the deck will be supported by both cables and the structure itself. This design reduces the overall height of the two towers as req
    Read More
  • Italians to tender for Libyan project
    May 28, 2012
    Work on the Libyan section of the North African coastal highway now looks set to go ahead. Two consortia from Italy are to tender for the pre-qualifying stage of the US$3 billion project. The highway will run some 1,700km from Libya's border with Tunisia all the way to the border with Egypt. This is the final section in the new highway running all the way from Morocco in North West Africa to Egypt in the North East.
    Read More
  • More on the Newmarket Viaduct replacement
    June 15, 2012
    When it was completed in 1965 – just six years after the Auckland Harbour Bridge – the six-lane Newmarket Viaduct with its tall, slender piers was something of an engineering wonder, the first of its kind in the Southern Hemisphere. Forty years on it had become a much-maligned contributor to Auckland’s chronic traffic congestion, too weak seismically to withstand the heaviest loaded trucks let alone a severe earthquake, so narrow in the shoulders that any accident stopped traffic flow and made it difficult
    Read More
  • Drainage for new Wear Crossing in UK
    January 21, 2016
    In the UK the Lanes Group is carrying out the contract to build specialist drainage for the New Wear Bridge in Sunderland. The Lanes Group will carry out this work for the joint venture partners building the new bridge link.
    Read More

Highlighted Content