Italy’s horrific bridge collapse is a sign of a wider problem

The shocking collapse of a major highway bridge in the Italian city of Genoa has highlighted a major problem with regard to poor infrastructure condition in the country. Causing multiple fatalities, the cable-stayed Morandi Bridge suffered a spectacular failure of a central support. Homes have had to be evacuated and it seems likely that the bridge, opened in 1967, will now have to be demolished. However, warnings had been given. The unusual bridge design, with its thin deck and reinforced concrete stays
January 7, 2019 Read time: 3 mins
The shocking collapse of a major highway bridge in the Italian city of Genoa has highlighted a major problem with regard to poor infrastructure condition in the country. Causing multiple fatalities, the cable-stayed Morandi Bridge suffered a spectacular failure of a central support. Homes have had to be evacuated and it seems likely that the bridge, opened in 1967, will now have to be demolished.


However, warnings had been given. The unusual bridge design, with its thin deck and reinforced concrete stays, had been subject to frequent maintenance periods in the past. Two years ago a professor of engineering from Genoa University voiced concern over the condition of the Morandi Bridge. It is worth noting that the Wadi el Kuf Bridge in Libya by the same designer, Riccardo Morandi, has a similar arrangement of supports and cable stays. The Libyan bridge, first opened in 1972, was closed due to structural problems in 2017.

Questions have been asked as to why so many structures in Italy, particularly in the south, are suffering so badly from age. The quality of materials used during construction have been highly suspect in some instances, with organised crime linked to the poor engineering performance of many structures. Italy has seen 12 bridge collapses in recent years, four of which occurred in the south of the country.

Not since the collapse of the I-35 West bridge in Minneapolis in 2007 has there been such a public bridge disaster in a western developed nation. The I-35 W disaster in the US sparked examinations of other structures, showing some 20-25% of US bridges to be structurally deficient.

And nor is the problem restricted to Italy or the US. France, Germany and the UK for example all have their share of ageing bridges. It is a sign of the times, as structures erected in the 50s, 60s and 70s succumb to wear and tear. In many instances the wear can also be attributed to factors that were not properly understood at the time of design construction, such as the risk of long-term corrosion of unprotected reinforcing steel caused by chloride attack.

Bear in mind too that highways and bridges built in the 1960s were designed to handle far lower traffic volumes. For example, the UK’s Forth Road Bridge carried around 4 million vehicles/year after it was opened in 1964 and was designed to handle up to 11 million vehicles/year. However, by the time it was replaced by the new Queensferry Crossing, around 24 million vehicles/year were using the link. This is only part of the picture. Trucks had GVWs of just 20tonnes or so in the 1960s, compared with a maximum permitted weight of 44tonnes now in Europe, while a far higher percentage of freight is now carried by road. Given that stress levels increase exponentially with weight, using a rough calculation it can be assumed that the Forth Road Bridge was handling something like 16 times the daily stresses it had been designed for. No small wonder then that it wore out.

It would be naïve indeed to assume that crumbling transport infrastructure is solely an Italian problem stemming from ‘Mafia concrete’.

Related Content

  • Increased crash risk for young drivers when tired
    May 2, 2012
    A new study by researchers at the University of Bologna in Italy suggests that young drivers are twice as likely to have a crash if they felt sleepy at the wheel or have had problems sleeping. The study of students found that 56% who'd been involved in at least one accident said they had driven despite feeling sleepy, compared with 35% of those who had not been in a crash. According to the UK motoring organisation the RAC, driver sleepiness is estimated to account for around 20% of accidents on major roads
    Read More
  • Defective eyesight, a road safety concern?
    February 16, 2012
    Failing eyesight presents safety problems for Europe's older drivers. A new report highlights substantial variation in the assessment of drivers' vision across Europe, and recommends that Member States make moves to better assess drivers' vision. Checking the vision of drivers plays a valuable role in the EU's target of halving road deaths across the EU by 2020. The aim is to achieve this road safety improvement by legislative means that change driver behaviour, raise the technical standards of vehicles and
    Read More
  • Repair, recycling and warm mix technology at Italy’s Asphaltica exibition
    May 15, 2017
    As the name might suggest, the Asphaltica show in Verona, Italy was a good place to catch up on new ideas and applications for bitumen technology. Kristina Smith picked out a few highlights. Like many of its European neighbours, much of Italy’s road network is in dire need of love and attention. This was a constant theme for the Asphaltica show which was held alongside SaMoTer in Verona from 22-25 February. Speaking at the opening ceremony for the two shows, Michele Turrini, president of SITEB, which repres
    Read More
  • VIDEO – Explosive blast apart redundant US bridge
    July 13, 2015
    The Donora-Webster Bridge over the Monongahela River in the US has been demolished using explosives. The ageing structure spanned the Monongahela River, connecting Washington and Westmoreland Counties in Pennsylvania. The bridge was built in 1908 and originally carried a rail link but in 1938 the tracks were removed and the structure was modified so that it could handle motor vehicle traffic instead. The Donora-Webster Bridge linked Route 837 on the west side of the Monongahela River with Route 906 on the east bank.
    Read More

Highlighted Content