Polish public procurement practices pilloried

Comments by the European Construction Industry Federation (FIEC) have thrown the spotlight on Polish public procurement practices. "We have never ever heard such outspoken criticism about procurement practice and contracting authorities in a single country by so many contractors from so many different enterprises and countries," commented Ulrich Paetzold, director general of FIEC.
November 29, 2012 Read time: 2 mins

Comments by the 6164 European Construction Industry Federation (FIEC) have thrown the spotlight on Polish public procurement practices. "We have never ever heard such outspoken criticism about procurement practice and contracting authorities in a single country by so many contractors from so many different enterprises and countries," commented Ulrich Paetzold, director general of FIEC.

Contractors active in public works contracts in Poland are profoundly worried about the severe deterioration of public procurement rules and practice over the last years. Changes of both the Public Procurement Law and the internationally recognised FIDIC contract conditions have led to a situation considered unfair, counter-productive and unacceptable by the contractors.

"And all of these companies have decades of worldwide experience with public procurement and FIDIC standard forms of contract," added Frank Kehlenbach, director of EIC, the European International Contractors, "but this experience does not help them in Poland, given the reluctance of public clients to perform their part of the job."

Two major highway contracts in particular have resulted in lengthy legal battles. Austrian contractor 1332 Alpine Bau became involved in one torturous court dispute with the Polish authorities. The award of a highway contract to a Chinese firm offering a low bid then precipitated another complex legal case when the firm did not meet targets and had its contract terminated.

A combination of poorly prepared tenders, a generally unfair attitude towards contractors and the non-respect of contractual obligations by public clients not only raises the question of professionalism on the demand side but also leads to a number of concerns regarding Internal Market issues, such as lack of transparency and proportionality, as well as discrimination and freedom to provide services. If this development cannot be stopped and reversed, then this inefficiency in spending European funds could lead the EU to reviewing its funding and lending policies which have provided Poland with almost € 68 billion for investment. At present at least €2 billion is blocked by litigation in the Polish courts and this amount is rapidly increasing.

For more information on companies in this article

Related Content

  • Investing in road transport boost economies
    April 30, 2015
    Transport investment faces a shortfall that can perhaps never be breached – David Arminas writes There “will never be sufficient funds for all planned road activities,” said Ben Gericke, transport specialist at The World Bank. The road maintenance industry is going to have to use the best possible contract strategy to win the investment it needs. Speaking at the PPRS Paris 2015 Pavement Preservation and Recycling Summit, Gericke said that the best way for the global highway construction and road maint
    Read More
  • New Polish government of Jaroslaw Kaczynski rethinks road spend
    December 7, 2015
    Poland might double road spend after the new government criticised spending calculations up to 2025 put together by the previous administration. The Vice-Minister of Infrastructure said expenditure would need to nearly double to around €47 billion for the planned new dual carriageways and motorways. A report by daily economic and political newspaper Rzeczpospolita said the government is calling the estimate of €3.7 million to build a 1km of road “unrealistic”. The rethink comes after Poland's euros
    Read More
  • Public-private participation for highway law enforcement
    April 18, 2017
    In some countries, public-private partnerships for road traffic law enforcement are helping to greatly reduce traffic fatalities. But careful implementation is essential, according to a new white paper. Big brother is watching you. Speed cameras are just a cash cow for local authorities. Police use them to keep their speeding ticket statistics high. The list of suspicions goes on. But there is nothing suspicious about road deaths, says Philip Wijers, chairman of the sub-committee on enforcement at the US-ba
    Read More
  • Funding problems for major Polish highway project
    May 9, 2012
    The long tale of woe concerning Poland’s troubled A2 highway project looks set to continue with the latest developments in the case. The Chinese contractor China Overseas Engineering Group Co (Covec) is appealing against a decision made by the Polish national road authority GDDKiA. The Polish authorities cancelled the contract that COVEC had previously been awarded to build a section of the A2 highway between Warsaw and Lodz.
    Read More

Highlighted Content