Polish public procurement practices pilloried

Comments by the European Construction Industry Federation (FIEC) have thrown the spotlight on Polish public procurement practices. "We have never ever heard such outspoken criticism about procurement practice and contracting authorities in a single country by so many contractors from so many different enterprises and countries," commented Ulrich Paetzold, director general of FIEC.
November 29, 2012 Read time: 2 mins

Comments by the 6164 European Construction Industry Federation (FIEC) have thrown the spotlight on Polish public procurement practices. "We have never ever heard such outspoken criticism about procurement practice and contracting authorities in a single country by so many contractors from so many different enterprises and countries," commented Ulrich Paetzold, director general of FIEC.

Contractors active in public works contracts in Poland are profoundly worried about the severe deterioration of public procurement rules and practice over the last years. Changes of both the Public Procurement Law and the internationally recognised FIDIC contract conditions have led to a situation considered unfair, counter-productive and unacceptable by the contractors.

"And all of these companies have decades of worldwide experience with public procurement and FIDIC standard forms of contract," added Frank Kehlenbach, director of EIC, the European International Contractors, "but this experience does not help them in Poland, given the reluctance of public clients to perform their part of the job."

Two major highway contracts in particular have resulted in lengthy legal battles. Austrian contractor 1332 Alpine Bau became involved in one torturous court dispute with the Polish authorities. The award of a highway contract to a Chinese firm offering a low bid then precipitated another complex legal case when the firm did not meet targets and had its contract terminated.

A combination of poorly prepared tenders, a generally unfair attitude towards contractors and the non-respect of contractual obligations by public clients not only raises the question of professionalism on the demand side but also leads to a number of concerns regarding Internal Market issues, such as lack of transparency and proportionality, as well as discrimination and freedom to provide services. If this development cannot be stopped and reversed, then this inefficiency in spending European funds could lead the EU to reviewing its funding and lending policies which have provided Poland with almost € 68 billion for investment. At present at least €2 billion is blocked by litigation in the Polish courts and this amount is rapidly increasing.

For more information on companies in this article

Related Content

  • FIEC criticises contract awards and procurement practices
    January 20, 2014
    Europe’s contractors’ association, the FIEC, has criticised the EU’s new public procurement package, describing it as a missed opportunity. “The EU institutions did not seize the opportunity to solve one of the most severe shortcomings of the existing public procurement directives,” said Ulrich Paetzold, FIEC director general. “I mean by that the identification and treatment of abnormally low tenders, which is a real curse in the construction sector.” Today’s adoption by the European Parliament of the thre
    Read More
  • Poland's complex road dispute
    March 1, 2012
    The complex legal case between the Polish General Directorate for National Roads and Motorways (GDDKiA) and Austrian contractor Alpine Bau is continuing in the Polish courts.
    Read More
  • GDDKiA to call 50 tenders in Poland worth combined €7.65 billion
    May 17, 2013
    Polish road authority GDDKiA has approved the calling of 50 tenders for road construction projects worth a combined US$9.85 billion (PLN 32bn). GDDKiA has decided to allow contractors to carry out changes in one half of the projects supplied by the authority, which will, it says, allow the relations between the investor and the contractor to become more efficient. However, it can also act as an encouragement of the building companies to save on quality. Work on the road construction projects being put up fo
    Read More
  • Poland’s GDDKiA promises to improve road procurement processes
    January 12, 2015
    The Polish national roads authority GDDKiA has said that it will no longer look for the cheapest offer in road-building tenders. Instead, it will, in line with European Union requirements, consider whole life cycle factors such as durability, cost of exploitation and quality. Poland has long been criticised by the road construction industry, both within the country and in the rest of Europe, for handing out tender wins to the lowest bidder with scant regard for life-cycle costs. The government has also b
    Read More

Highlighted Content