Skip to main content

Europe's Galileo satellite navigation project is a ''stupid idea''

The head of the German firm contracted to build 14 satellites for Europe's Galileo satellite navigation system called the entire project a "stupid idea," according to a leaked diplomatic cable published in Norway's Aftenposten newspaper.The head of the German firm contracted to build 14 satellites for Europe’s Galileo satellite navigation system called the entire project a "stupid idea," according to a leaked diplomatic cable published in Norway’s Aftenposten newspaper. Aftenposten said the cable quotes Be
March 6, 2012 Read time: 2 mins
The head of the German firm contracted to build 14 satellites for Europe’s Galileo satellite navigation system called the entire project a "stupid idea," according to a leaked diplomatic cable published in Norway’s Aftenposten newspaper.

Aftenposten said the cable quotes Berry Smutny, CEO of OHB-System AG, telling American diplomats at the US Embassy in Berlin during a meeting on 2 October, 2009, that the entire project was "a waste of EU taxpayers' money championed by French interests."

However, the cable added that Smutny said he would "gladly accept contracts to build the satellites," and that he believed that European navigational needs could already be served by GPS instead of Galileo.

Last Thursday, in response to the Aftenposten story, OHB issued a statement saying that Smutny denies making the reported comments. Yesterday, however, the OHB supervisory board announced that it had passed a unanimous resolution to revoke Smutny’s appointment to the position of CEO of the company.

“The General Assembly and the Supervisory Board saw no alternative to this decision in order to effectively avert any further damage to the company on the part of customers, political representatives and the public at large,” the company stated.

OHB’s contract to build 14 satellites that will be used in the Galileo constellation is worth US$742 million.

Meanwhile, today, the EC will present its midterm review on progress in the development of Europe’s satellite navigation programmes to date, including the start of operations of the EGNOS system, the deployment of two experimental satellites and the allotment of the necessary construction and engineering work to subcontractors. In addition the future directions of Galileo are considered in the review.

Related Content

  • Tolling innovation
    January 4, 2013
    Leading European tolling solution companies are involved in a number of innovative tolling projects across the continent and further afield. Guy Woodford looks at some of the latest Siemens Mobility & Logistics (SML) has received orders from Eurotoll and Total, two of France’s largest electronic toll on-board unit issuers, to supply technology for the new French toll collection system. The equipment comprises on-board units for the vehicles as well as the electronic detection system. The SML orders’, worth
  • A history lesson in private public partnerships
    February 15, 2012
    Michel Démarre gives some historical insights into public-private partnerships conceived to implement urban infrastructure projects, a concept that surprisingly dates back to as early as the 13th century!
  • Europe-Asia road link
    February 9, 2017
    The governments of China, Kazakhstan, Belarus and Russia have finally approved a project for the building of a new transcontinental road, which will connect Asia and Europe. The new route is much-needed and will speed the transportation of cargo between the two continents, according to Maxim Sokolov, Russia’s Minister of Transport. The idea for the building of the road was first proposed by the European Commission around 2005. It was prompted by the ever growing volume of trade between the EU and Chin
  • A history lesson in private public partnerships
    April 12, 2012
    Michel Démarre gives some historical insights into public-private partnerships conceived to implement urban infrastructure projects, a concept that surprisingly dates back to as early as the 13th century! All over the world today, the role of public authorities in the process of planning and, in most cases, designing, financing and procuring urban roads is paramount. Even for modifications to existing roads, decisions are made by these public authorities (usually after due consultation with the population)