Skip to main content

Research shows male drivers more likely to overtake rashly

A new survey carried out in the UK reveals that male drivers are more likely to risk lives by overtaking blind and speeding on rural roads. As a result male drivers are being urged to be more careful. The survey was carried out jointly by safety body Brake and insurance firm Direct Line. The data reveals that 24% of drivers risk catastrophic head-on crashes by overtaking blind, while 44% admit speeding at over the national speed limit of 96km/h (60mph) on rural roads. Men are much more likely to take these
July 1, 2013 Read time: 4 mins

A new survey carried out in the UK reveals that male drivers are more likely to risk lives by overtaking blind and speeding on rural roads. As a result male drivers are being urged to be more careful

The survey was carried out jointly by safety body 3963 Brake and insurance firm 3962 Direct Line. The data reveals that 24% of drivers risk catastrophic head-on crashes by overtaking blind, while 44% admit speeding at over the national speed limit of 96km/h (60mph) on rural roads.

Men are much more likely to take these deadly risks than women, and more than twice as likely to have been involved in an overtaking near-miss or incident. The Brake and Direct Line survey of 1,000 UK drivers also found 18% of women admitted overtaking when they could not be certain nothing was coming, in the past year. It showed 20% of men and 9% of women have been involved in an overtaking near-miss or incident while driving in the past year. And 54% of all drivers have witnessed an overtaking near-miss or incident by another driver in the past year, with 19% experiencing a vehicle approaching on their side of the road. Some 52% of women have been afraid when travelling as a passenger when their driver has overtaken another vehicle in the past year, compared to 44% of men. Some 24% of women have broken the 96km/h national speed limit on a rural road, and men are twice as likely to do this monthly or more (20% compared to 9%). In 2011, six in 10 UK road deaths were on rural roads, equating to 1,197 people losing their lives. Four in 10 serious injuries were on rural roads, equating to 9,952 people suffering serious and often long-lasting or permanent harm. Three in four people killed on UK roads are male.

Brake is also pressing for government and local authority action to lower speed limits on rural roads and implement measures to deter speeding and overtaking, especially at crash black-spots and roads that pass through rural communities. Brake is highlighting that simple, often low-cost engineering measures can significantly reduce casualties. It is also calling for the UK government to get tough on rural road risk by funding wider traffic enforcement and running publicity campaigns to raise awareness of the dangers involved in driving too fast and overtaking.

It seems likely that the data revealed by this survey will also be applicable to other European nations. The macho culture surrounding driving is by no means restricted to the UK and the situation could even be much worse in some other European countries, where drinking and driving amongst male drivers is still more widespread for example.

Many drivers mistakenly think rural roads are safer, because they are often quieter. In reality, they are shared by all types of road users and there are many hazards, such as tight bends, blind corners and brows, and narrow roads. This means drivers may have little time to react to hazards, and this is reduced considerably by driving faster. At 96km/h, a driver's stopping distance is 73m. The high speeds with which many people navigate these roads also mean that crashes are more likely to cause serious injuries or death than on slower roads. In fact, rural roads are the most dangerous for all kinds of road user. Overtaking on single carriageways is dangerous, given that it involves driving on the wrong side of the road at speed. It is impossible for drivers to accurately judge the speed and distance of approaching traffic, and whether they have sufficient clear road to complete the manoeuvre. They also cannot be certain the vehicle they are overtaking will not speed up. Where overtaking is concerned, a small error of judgement can easily be fatal. There is clear evidence that in general male drivers take more risks, are hurt or killed more, and cause more deaths on roads than women. Some researchers argue it is down to biology, others say this is about societal expectations placed on boys from a young age, rewarding riskier behaviour. But whatever the reasons, it is certain that risk-taking on roads leads to terrible consequences for many men and women every day.

For more information on companies in this article

Related Content

  • Men more likely to pass UK driving test than women, says IAM research
    September 19, 2012
    British men are 6.4% more likely than British women to pass their practical driving test, according to road safety charity the IAM. But while young men are more likely to pass their driving test, they are also three times more likely to be killed or seriously injured (KSI) behind the wheel. The IAM findings are a result of analysing pass rates statistics from the Department for Transport (DfT) published in August 2012 for the financial year 2011-2012.
  • Argentinan study backs up previous research highlighting women safer drivers than males
    December 8, 2014
    A study carried out in Argentina by NGO Luchemos por la Vida reveals that female drivers are safer than male drivers. The study was based on data from 4,724 drivers in Buenos Aires city. The results reveal that women drivers take fewer risks and are less likely to break the law than male drivers. Women drivers wear seat belts more than men, are less likely to drive through red lights and are also less likely to use a phone while behind the wheel. The findings match previous international studies.
  • Brake calls for tougher sentences for UK road death drivers
    May 28, 2014
    UK road safety charity Brake has renewed calls for tougher charges and penalties for drivers who kill and injure following the publication of British government criminal justice figures for 2013. The figures show the large proportion of drivers who kill and seriously injure being let off with relatively low penalties, reinforcing the importance of a forthcoming review of charges and penalties, recently announced by government. In total, 438 drivers were convicted of causing death or bodily harm. Just over
  • Simple road safety measures save lives
    February 15, 2012
    Elementary road safety measures quickly pay back the costs of investment and, more importantly, help save lives as Patrick Smith reports. More than 300 people in the UK are alive today or have avoided the prospect of a lifetime of special care because just 15 roads have had simple improvements put in place.