Skip to main content

ASECAP: Cooperation needed for better toll-road risk management

Toll operators must offer a level of service for which drivers are prepared to pay because in many cases, drivers have alternative free-use routes. Incentives to attract drivers onto toll roads must include shorter and reliable journey times as well smooth and trouble free travel – all at an affordable price. Private companies running toll roads face the same difficulties as any other commercial entity, in particular financing construction before any toll revenue can be collected. Hardly surprising that fin
May 31, 2017 Read time: 3 mins
Guy Chetrit: PPPs may not be the answer
Toll operators must offer a level of service for which drivers are prepared to pay because in many cases, drivers have alternative free-use routes. Incentives to attract drivers onto toll roads must include shorter and reliable journey times as well smooth and trouble free travel – all at an affordable price.

Private companies running toll roads face the same difficulties as any other commercial entity, in particular financing construction before any toll revenue can be collected. Hardly surprising that financing was one of the major themes at a recent Study and Information Days event put on by 1103 ASECAP, the European association of toll concessionaires.

The stakes are high. ASECAP’s members operate more than 50,000km of tolled highways. Across the Atlantic, members of the International Bridge Tunnel and Turnpike Association (2793 IBTTA), ASECAP’s North American equivalent, operate more than 8,500km of highway.

A client’s tender document for a planned toll road includes all the details including the road’s proposed route and design, land surveys and – importantly - estimates of expected traffic volumes. Potential bidders base their calculations upon this data.

However, should there be significant differences between the details provided and reality, the winning bidder can make a claim for changes to the contract – especially in terms of payment. The construction phase represents one of the biggest risks - particularly as the road may not be open and therefore the concessionaire would not be receiving any toll revenue.

The moment the contract is signed, “the partnership ends and the fighting begins. Once the contract is signed it’s a zero-sum game: my gain is your loss,” said José Viegas, secretary general of the 1102 International Transport Forum.

He urged delegates, which included local authorities, concessionaires and contractors, to cooperate and not let lawyers take control.

One of the biggest changes in the tolling industry working its way through the system is European Union Directive 2014/23/EU which redefines the European model of a concession. In the new regulations, the concessionaire must accept the risk of failure. In tolling that often relates to unexpected difficulties during construction of the volume of traffic that use the new road. This introduces a degree of uncertainly which, Guy Chetrit of the 1054 European Investment bank, told the conference, means “PPPs [public-private partnerships] are not the right vehicle for funding toll road construction as a PPP needs certainty.”

For more information on companies in this article

Related Content

  • Further co-operation between ASECAP and GSA
    May 30, 2012
    An extension to the existing collaboration between ASECAP and the European GNSS Agency (GSA) will increase efficiency. The aim is to exchange knowledge and experience and to examine together the potential and the use of GNSS applications in highway operations. This arrangement follows on from the 40th ASECAP Study and Information Days, which took place in Turin, Italy recently. The GSA supports the use of European GNSS in road transport to improve traffic management and road safety and reduce CO2 emissions.
  • Report claims that Germany’s toll roads are too expensive
    January 4, 2016
    Toll roads built in Germany under public-private partnerships deals has been costing taxpayers much more than originally planned, a government spending watchdog has claimed. An internal report the German Federal Audit Office (BRH) has criticised PPP plans for private motorway construction as laid out by the Minister of Transport and Digital Infrastructure Alexander Dobrindt. According to the report in the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, five out of the total six motorways built through a PPP deal resu
  • Eurasphalt & Eurobitume 2016 Congress calls for better communication
    August 5, 2016
    The bitumen industry needs to learn how to communicate with road owners, road users, and communities. This was one of the underlying themes to emerge from the Eurasphalt & Eurobitume 2016 Congress, held in the Czech capital Prague in June. Kristina Smith was there.
  • IRF senior executives professional development 2012
    April 11, 2012
    Register today for one of the world’s foremost continuing professional development programmes tailored to the needs of senior road professionals. Organised by the University of Birmingham (UK) in association with IRF Geneva, the Senior Road Executives (SRE) Programme has established an international reputation as an essential ‘must attend’ annual event for senior road professionals from across the world.